By Dan Walsh
“Quite romantic” was Ivan Cleary’s wry description of the NRL’s round one scheduling.
Back to Brisbane, where the final scene of Penrith’s first season without a premiership since 2020 played out. No need for revenge.
And as Cleary noted at the start of the week – again with half a smirk – “you can’t take the [premiership] rings off them; they earned them.”
The last time Penrith were at Suncorp Stadium, they blinked with their season on the line: a 14-0 half-time lead in their keeping; a near-perfect first 40 minutes with 57 per cent of possession.
Not exactly butchered, because the Broncos defended like demons in one of the modern era’s epic preliminary finals, and well and truly won a classic contest. The Panthers didn’t beat themselves.
However, for the first time since the start of their all-conquering dynasty, they did cough up a 12-point lead without recovering it.
There’s been no popcorn and group therapy rewatch of September’s 16-14 loss to the eventual premiers. But the key moments where Penrith failed to put Brisbane away have loomed large all the same this summer.
“We’ve had enough time to digest where we went wrong and where we missed the mark,” fullback Dylan Edwards said.
“We’ve taken snippets from that prelim throughout our pre-season, but no specific focus on watching that game and trying to fuel that fire going into that game [round one].
“Just little focus areas. We didn’t finish the game well enough, and we were probably guilty of that a lot of the time throughout the season – just staying in that game for the full 80 [minutes].
“The Broncos, they were the best at it, finishing games and being able to come over the top of teams … we’ve addressed that.”
So, what were the moments that mattered most, the ones Penrith so often nailed throughout their run to four straight titles?
Probably the three sets and 15 straight tackles the Panthers had hammering Brisbane’s line with 16 minutes to play while holding an eight-point lead.
Both sides favoured their respective left edges last year, which proved among the NRL’s most dangerous: the Broncos’ 65 tries down that channel were the most scored by any team; Penrith’s 54 ranked third in the league.
But the Panthers found no joy hammering Brisbane’s right side through Casey McLean and Blaize Talagi last September, and went that way too often.
That said, one of Nathan Cleary’s grubbers could easily have ricocheted Penrith’s way instead of Brisbane’s. And it still took Payne Haas’ otherworldly feat of endurance – while bleeding like a heavyweight champion – to snuff out a particularly threatening 66th-minute kick.
Hindsight’s a wonderful thing, especially for sporting hacks. But if Penrith and Cleary had their time again, they’d have taken the easy penalty shot at goal, and what could have been a 16-6 lead, when Ezra Mam conceded the most blatant of escort penalties in the 61st minute.
Cooper Cronk questioned the decision in commentary as, once again, a left-side shift broke down when Luke Garner couldn’t hang onto Cleary’s short ball.
And with Brisbane riding momentum like no one else in rugby league can, for once, Penrith were unable to pull the game out of the fire. Needing a two-point field goal to force the contest into golden point, the Panthers’ last set went awry.
Cleary’s scramble to get in position left him under pressure and eventually having to find Edwards for a Hail Mary shot – the final play of Penrith’s season.
When the champion No.7 botched a clutch field goal attempt in a rare mid-2022 loss to Parramatta, the Herald documented the week of extra practice Cleary spent on long-range drop punts on the training paddock.
With his hamstrings in mind, Cleary has dialled back his days of nigh-obsessive, endless repetitions.
But with an entire summer to consider not winning a premiership for once, and how different things could have been, Cleary snr can see where the Panthers’ heads are at.
“It was a different feeling last year, for sure,” he said.
“I feel like there was definitely some fire in that. It certainly looks that way.”